Funds Insider - Opening the door to funds

Welcome to the Citywire Funds Insider Forums, where members share investment ideas and discuss everything to do with their money.

You'll need to log in or set up an account to start new discussions or reply to existing ones. See you inside!

Notification

Icon
Error

In The News...
Robin B
Posted: 31 October 2024 07:06:05(UTC)

Joined: 01/04/2024(UTC)
Posts: 1,523

Thanks: 1519 times
Was thanked: 4636 time(s) in 1247 post(s)
2 users thanked Robin B for this post.
Nigel Harris on 31/10/2024(UTC), Guest on 31/10/2024(UTC)
Robin B
Posted: 31 October 2024 08:17:58(UTC)

Joined: 01/04/2024(UTC)
Posts: 1,523

Thanks: 1519 times
Was thanked: 4636 time(s) in 1247 post(s)
Posting this here so t'other thread isn't taken "off topic"...

Robin B;323819 wrote:


Obviously, there are many downsides to living in Russia...

But then again, in this country you can be subjected to turbo charged court proceedings and sent to prison for several years for merely standing in the street with a sign, mimicking prayer (in relation to a specific religion), shouting at the police, and posting a foolish tweet online...



Just going to quote myself because, interestingly, after writing that yesterday evening I find the article below in today's Spectator...

I don't think it boils down to much in terms of numbers and probably more people have gone in the other direction since the war started, but those of us who care to think about things might find some food for thought here and reflect on our own country, and the West generally.

The UK: high taxes, highest energy prices in the developed world, 100% debt to GDP ratio, falling living standards; crap public services, congested infrastructure; poor law and order; increasingly corrupt state and media that tell endless lies; curtailments on freedoms, a two tier and discriminatory justice system; moral degeneracy everywhere; patriotism and traditional values diminished, ridiculed and classified as "far right"; left wing extremism is the norm in politics and culture, importing problems and terrorism from elsewhere... If you are even moderately conservative, who is there to vote for in this so called democracy?

Russia has income taxes of 13-15%, debt to GDP ratio of only 17%, inflation rate of 8.5% balanced by economic growth of 4.5% (and this is all despite it fighting a war for the past 2.5 years).

The Western Conservatives Moving to Russia

https://www.spectator.co.uk/arti...atives-moving-to-russia/

Some snippets...

"Standley is a 45-year-old financial services consultant from Solihull in the West Midlands. In Moscow, where he has lived since 2012, Standley says he has found ‘economic opportunity… the most beautiful girls in the world’ and – perhaps most importantly – ‘freedom’. Russia is ‘a million times more free [than the UK] in terms of freedom in every aspect and context, even freedom of speech’."

...

‘A lot of people in America are tired of the LGBT agenda being pushed on them by Hollywood and media organisations and the government,’ says Crane, a former medical technician who quit after refusing to administer Covid vaccines. ‘Look at [western] economies right now, look at their people. Look at the amount of homeless people on the streets, the amount of drug addicts. They’re rejecting moral values. We see a massive decline in western societies.’

...

"...he says he’d never move back to the UK. Russia is ‘such a diverse country. It’s a very free country in terms of what you want to say. Taxation is very low here’."

...

‘People are traditional and normal here,’ he says. ‘Men act like men, women act like women.’ In his home in rural Kansas, by Schutzman’s account, he couldn’t take his kids to the store without them seeing trans people. In Russia, ‘people don’t walk up to my wife and mock her for having so many children’.

Discuss.
2 users thanked Robin B for this post.
Guest on 31/10/2024(UTC), Dexi on 31/10/2024(UTC)
ANDREW FOSTER
Posted: 31 October 2024 09:52:59(UTC)

Joined: 23/07/2019(UTC)
Posts: 8,120

Thanks: 11360 times
Was thanked: 18230 time(s) in 5978 post(s)
Robin B;323998 wrote:



Russia has income taxes of 13-15%, debt to GDP ratio of only 17%, inflation rate of 8.5% balanced by economic growth of 4.5% (and this is all despite it fighting a war for the past 2.5 years).



I asked for your source for these numbers... maybe you missed my question. Or maybe you didn't want to say 'Russian Official Figures' because of the hilarity and mockery that would follow..

I also notice you didn't mention Base Rate of 21%. Wonder why you omitted that? There is a reason that you blindside such important numbers, and that is that it clearly doesn't fit the 'thing you want to be true'. So you miss it out..

But I will try again... What is the source of your figures...?
2 users thanked ANDREW FOSTER for this post.
SF100 on 31/10/2024(UTC), Tim D on 31/10/2024(UTC)
Robin B
Posted: 31 October 2024 12:08:00(UTC)

Joined: 01/04/2024(UTC)
Posts: 1,523

Thanks: 1519 times
Was thanked: 4636 time(s) in 1247 post(s)
ANDREW FOSTER;324012 wrote:
Robin B;323998 wrote:



Russia has income taxes of 13-15%, debt to GDP ratio of only 17%, inflation rate of 8.5% balanced by economic growth of 4.5% (and this is all despite it fighting a war for the past 2.5 years).



I asked for your source for these numbers... maybe you missed my question. Or maybe you didn't want to say 'Russian Official Figures' because of the hilarity and mockery that would follow..

I also notice you didn't mention Base Rate of 21%. Wonder why you omitted that? There is a reason that you blindside such important numbers, and that is that it clearly doesn't fit the 'thing you want to be true'. So you miss it out..

But I will try again... What is the source of your figures...?


I have already responded to you on the other thread and respectfully so. I simply used Google and found five websites and news sources saying it is around 8?5%. I could not find any source suggesting a different figure. Why don't you provide your source if you think there is an alternative figure we should believe instead? Or perhaps you have a credible source that explains how the published inflation figures are untrustworthy compared to those of, say, the UK?
1 user thanked Robin B for this post.
Guest on 31/10/2024(UTC)
ANDREW FOSTER
Posted: 31 October 2024 12:28:13(UTC)

Joined: 23/07/2019(UTC)
Posts: 8,120

Thanks: 11360 times
Was thanked: 18230 time(s) in 5978 post(s)
Robin B;324056 wrote:
ANDREW FOSTER;324012 wrote:
Robin B;323998 wrote:



Russia has income taxes of 13-15%, debt to GDP ratio of only 17%, inflation rate of 8.5% balanced by economic growth of 4.5% (and this is all despite it fighting a war for the past 2.5 years).



I asked for your source for these numbers... maybe you missed my question. Or maybe you didn't want to say 'Russian Official Figures' because of the hilarity and mockery that would follow..

I also notice you didn't mention Base Rate of 21%. Wonder why you omitted that? There is a reason that you blindside such important numbers, and that is that it clearly doesn't fit the 'thing you want to be true'. So you miss it out..

But I will try again... What is the source of your figures...?


I have already responded to you on the other thread and respectfully so. I simply used Google and found five websites and news sources saying it is around 8?5%. I could not find any source suggesting a different figure. Why don't you provide your source if you think there is an alternative figure we should believe instead? Or perhaps you have a credible source that explains how the published inflation figures are untrustworthy compared to those of, say, the UK?


Because there is no credible figure publicly available. I doubt there is even a useful figure within Russia.

But you treat the sources you found as credable and cite them as if fact. That's amazingly naive, but fits your narrative.

But applying some thought, Western inflation reached 8-9% and was calmed with Base Rates of 4-6%.

The Russian Base rate is 21%. So from that you might take an educated guess at their real inflation rate.....

A 21% base rate is a Banana Republic number. And it's rising as the Ruble is falling. Yet you highlight the Russian economy as if it's some kind of success story?

I think you are seeing what you want to see and just cherry picking numbers that support a core belief.


1 user thanked ANDREW FOSTER for this post.
Tim D on 01/11/2024(UTC)
Robin B
Posted: 31 October 2024 15:03:17(UTC)

Joined: 01/04/2024(UTC)
Posts: 1,523

Thanks: 1519 times
Was thanked: 4636 time(s) in 1247 post(s)
ANDREW FOSTER;324062 wrote:
Robin B;324056 wrote:
ANDREW FOSTER;324012 wrote:
Robin B;323998 wrote:



Russia has income taxes of 13-15%, debt to GDP ratio of only 17%, inflation rate of 8.5% balanced by economic growth of 4.5% (and this is all despite it fighting a war for the past 2.5 years).



I asked for your source for these numbers... maybe you missed my question. Or maybe you didn't want to say 'Russian Official Figures' because of the hilarity and mockery that would follow..

I also notice you didn't mention Base Rate of 21%. Wonder why you omitted that? There is a reason that you blindside such important numbers, and that is that it clearly doesn't fit the 'thing you want to be true'. So you miss it out..

But I will try again... What is the source of your figures...?


I have already responded to you on the other thread and respectfully so. I simply used Google and found five websites and news sources saying it is around 8?5%. I could not find any source suggesting a different figure. Why don't you provide your source if you think there is an alternative figure we should believe instead? Or perhaps you have a credible source that explains how the published inflation figures are untrustworthy compared to those of, say, the UK?


Because there is no credible figure publicly available. I doubt there is even a useful figure within Russia.

But you treat the sources you found as credable and cite them as if fact. That's amazingly naive, but fits your narrative.

But applying some thought, Western inflation reached 8-9% and was calmed with Base Rates of 4-6%.

The Russian Base rate is 21%. So from that you might take an educated guess at their real inflation rate.....

A 21% base rate is a Banana Republic number. And it's rising as the Ruble is falling. Yet you highlight the Russian economy as if it's some kind of success story?

I think you are seeing what you want to see and just cherry picking numbers that support a core belief.



I doubt there is a useful figure for any country - all governments are being selective in the way they construct their inflation data. But there has to be some kind of standard that is trustworthy in general as it has a bearing on trade, currency valuation and exchange, investment. A lot of countries are trading with Russia - they won't want to end up holding a load of roubles where the data is totally unreliable. Or they might be getting ripped off when doing business. If the data on, e.g. inflation, isn't to be believed, then the currency could potentially be worthless.

It is your perspective that is the more unconvincing as you seem to be saying that the Russian economic data is a total pack of lies but don't have any basis for making this claim at all and are simply guessing that the inflation rate is higher by mere inference. I gave reasons why they might have hiked rates so much on the other thread. Their country is at war, seems to be trading effectively with most of the world, and they anticipate inflation rising more so want to take robust action now? Lots of possibilities.

It is also telling that you've focused specifically on inflation. I referred to several metrics, along with other observations that are nothing to do with the economy.

I think it is you who is driven by a narrative. I merely invited others to engage in a thought experiment and consider the state of their own country.
1 user thanked Robin B for this post.
Guest on 01/11/2024(UTC)
Robin B
Posted: 31 October 2024 22:57:00(UTC)

Joined: 01/04/2024(UTC)
Posts: 1,523

Thanks: 1519 times
Was thanked: 4636 time(s) in 1247 post(s)
Experts say they would've been advised within hours of the house being searched.
3 users thanked Robin B for this post.
Jay P on 31/10/2024(UTC), Guest on 01/11/2024(UTC), stephen_s on 01/11/2024(UTC)
Robin B
Posted: 31 October 2024 23:45:31(UTC)

Joined: 01/04/2024(UTC)
Posts: 1,523

Thanks: 1519 times
Was thanked: 4636 time(s) in 1247 post(s)
61 year old grandfather, sentenced to 2 years and 8 months in prison through turbo charged court process and with little legal representation. He was found to have shouted and held up a sign. That thing left wing protestors do on a weekly basis without any consequence

He committed suicide in his cell by hanging.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c3vlwxw6wweo.amp

This doesn't seem just at all to me and it's yet another terrible look for Sneer in particular.

Has there ever been a worse government?
3 users thanked Robin B for this post.
Neminem Laedit on 01/11/2024(UTC), Guest on 01/11/2024(UTC), stephen_s on 01/11/2024(UTC)
ben ski
Posted: 31 October 2024 23:54:21(UTC)

Joined: 15/01/2016(UTC)
Posts: 1,365

Thanks: 429 times
Was thanked: 3942 time(s) in 1020 post(s)
Far left and far right are both collectivist cults, and examples of how people are politicised to become pawns for an elite that doesn't care about them or their phoney politics one bit.

But to get this Marxist nonsense out of our legal system and media, it has to be regulated out of higher education... There's no point fighting it on the streets or comments sections – universities are indoctrination camps for this stuff, and often little else... Fighting and division is what they want.
1 user thanked ben ski for this post.
stephen_s on 01/11/2024(UTC)
Neminem Laedit
Posted: 01 November 2024 01:04:33(UTC)

Joined: 17/09/2018(UTC)
Posts: 1,473

Thanks: 1011 times
Was thanked: 2019 time(s) in 822 post(s)
1 user thanked Neminem Laedit for this post.
Guest on 01/11/2024(UTC)
218 Pages«Previous page106107108109110Next page»
+ Reply to discussion

Markets

Other markets