Funds Insider - Opening the door to funds

Welcome to the Citywire Funds Insider Forums, where members share investment ideas and discuss everything to do with their money.

You'll need to log in or set up an account to start new discussions or reply to existing ones. See you inside!

Notification

Icon
Error

Politics and Economics-2017 Election
Prof Eman
Posted: 20 May 2017 16:14:03(UTC)
#1

Joined: 08/04/2010(UTC)
Posts: 480

A student asked me a question, and I could not think of an immediate answer. It was-
Why should I vote and if so how? He explained-
First we had conservatives sell the family silver, called it privatisation. Labour continued it.
Labour also sold the family gold.
Next we had the coalition, continuing the privatisation, plus cuts.
Then came conservatives, gave us Brexit, This resulted in a sharp fall in the value of the pound resulting in foreigners buying up our companies at a discount. Called inward investment of which we should be proud. The only problem with this is that these foreigners are likely to export the work abroad to cheaper wage areas. So is employment about to rise?
I was lost for words. Can anyone suggest an answer?
Mostly Retired
Posted: 20 May 2017 17:37:02(UTC)
#2

Joined: 24/04/2012(UTC)
Posts: 344

Thanks: 1544 times
Was thanked: 1286 time(s) in 302 post(s)
The easy part is "why vote" : The right to vote in a democratic process is a hard won liberty and the envy of many countries around the globe. People die for the right to vote, even if sometimes "none of the above" is our reaction to the inane antics of politicians. The second part is less clear!

Manifesto pledges are as solid as fog. One looks at general tenor of argument and direction, and then accepts that they are surprisingly fallible - stupid decisions are no respecter of political belief or original intention. The reality of our world in the UK is that we are buffeted by forces outside our narrow political environment and a "pledge" will be rapidly eviscerated on the altar of international developments. Terminology is invented to hide the truth or flatter the listener, rarely does it reflect the reality of the proposed action.

Equally, every decision made by political leaders can be heavily criticised with the benefit of hindsight (though I remain perplexed by the decision by one GB to sell gold at the strike price he did). My view is that one takes the broad direction and emphasis as the way to choose; but like all when we are really honest, I admit to being at least a little selfish for me and my family when voting!

(P.S. Feeling especially cynical this week :) )
3 users thanked Mostly Retired for this post.
Mr Helpful on 24/05/2017(UTC), banjofred on 16/06/2017(UTC), Samual Saunders on 30/07/2018(UTC)
Recently Redundant and Retired
Posted: 20 May 2017 22:13:07(UTC)
#3

Joined: 08/03/2011(UTC)
Posts: 334

I've been eligible to vote for many decades and can't remember a time when I haven't been appalled at the poor quality of politician and choice we are faced with each time to such an extent I rarely vote, the main exceptions being when my children asked about elections so I took them to the polling station to vote for me, quite a discussion ensued with four of us in the booth usually resulting in voting Monster Raving Loony or Natural Law, sometimes "none of the above".
With so many people these days studying politics, PLE etc. at university (about half the audience on any Question Time it seems) I would have expected our system to throw up something better than the spineless, incompetent and self-promoting charlatans we get on our ballot papers. Where are the alternatives ? Could anyone envisage Diane Abbott as Home Secretary ? Is she and her ilk the best our system has to offer as an alternative ? Or perhaps this is how our education system makes them, as compliant stereotypes rather than radical thinkers, as puppets of the system rather than leaders of our nation.
Prof.. ask yourself, is a bad vote any better than no vote ?
Prof Eman
Posted: 21 May 2017 11:44:39(UTC)
#4

Joined: 08/04/2010(UTC)
Posts: 480

One further point was made in terms of economic management.
Where is the investment that should have accrued from North Sea Oil?
dyfed
Posted: 21 May 2017 14:02:48(UTC)
#5

Joined: 01/09/2016(UTC)
Posts: 453

Thanks: 750 times
Was thanked: 691 time(s) in 283 post(s)
Prof Eman;46975 wrote:
One further point was made in terms of economic management.
Where is the investment that should have accrued from North Sea Oil?


Indeed: where is our equivalent of the Norwegian Sovereign Wealth Fund? Long gone....
1 user thanked dyfed for this post.
Alan Anderson on 28/05/2017(UTC)
xcity
Posted: 21 May 2017 19:32:52(UTC)
#7

Joined: 12/04/2015(UTC)
Posts: 566

Thanks: 108 times
Was thanked: 612 time(s) in 314 post(s)
Prof Eman;46953 wrote:
First we had conservatives sell the family silver, called it privatisation. Labour continued it.

The majority of what was sold constituted a money pit whilst in public hands. Politics got in the way of active management and necessary investment was hard to justify.
Personally, I think that the privatisation (and later sale) of the building societies by Boards and members was much more malign.
Performance of most of the privatised industries has been much better since their sale.
Keeping them and making them perform better in the public sector might have been a better trick, but not one that governments have been good at.
Prof Eman;46953 wrote:
Labour also sold the family gold.

Well, 'sold' is a word for it; at the time, most thought GB had virtually given it away.
Prof Eman;46953 wrote:
Next we had the coalition, continuing the privatisation, plus cuts.

Not really true. Massive nationalisation of the banks with sales of other assets to help pay for the nationalisation and massive borrowings.
And much though our politicians can be blamed for the insufficient regulation etc, the same problems were there throughout the developed world. And rather than simply having cuts there was also QE; unlike the EU.
Prof Eman;46953 wrote:
Then came conservatives, gave us Brexit,

Again untrue. Offered the opportunity for Brexit, but it was voters who decided to go for it - all political parties, apart form UKIP, were against.
Prof Eman;46953 wrote:
Brexit, This resulted in a sharp fall in the value of the pound resulting in foreigners buying up our companies at a discount. Called inward investment of which we should be proud. The only problem with this is that these foreigners are likely to export the work abroad to cheaper wage areas.

Sharp fall in the pound - true, but only partly because the £ is still higher than it was in the financial crisis.
Foreigners buying our companies at a discount - well no. Companies have often been sold to foreigners and there is only a discount if you think the £ should be higher. If you think it should be lower, and that the UK's future is grim, then we're stealing money from them.
And not many companies have changed hands (yet). And how many of those that have been sold are able to export jobs? ARM? It's mostly IP companies that have gone, not a lot of jobs to go to cheap wage areas.
Prof Eman;46953 wrote:

Why should I vote and if so how?
I was lost for words. Can anyone suggest an answer?

Advise him not to. That means he can blame all the dumb voters for anything the government does that he doesn't like, like his friends do.
10 users thanked xcity for this post.
Sara G on 21/05/2017(UTC), Keith Hilton on 21/05/2017(UTC), dd on 21/05/2017(UTC), john_r on 22/05/2017(UTC), Lawny on 22/05/2017(UTC), Alan Anderson on 28/05/2017(UTC), c brown on 29/05/2017(UTC), Andrew Smith 259 on 05/06/2017(UTC), jvl on 06/06/2017(UTC), Samual Saunders on 30/07/2018(UTC)
dd
Posted: 21 May 2017 20:51:28(UTC)
#6

Joined: 15/09/2010(UTC)
Posts: 281

dyfed;46979 wrote:
Prof Eman;46975 wrote:
One further point was made in terms of economic management.
Where is the investment that should have accrued from North Sea Oil?


Indeed: where is our equivalent of the Norwegian Sovereign Wealth Fund? Long gone....


I fear that much of it went on current expenditure, increased salaries and pensions for and expanded public sector under Labour, not sure what under Coalition/Conservatives.
Prof Eman
Posted: 22 May 2017 08:36:12(UTC)
#8

Joined: 08/04/2010(UTC)
Posts: 480

The advice so far is-
Register to vote, i.e "to-day" which is the last day.
Then at least you have the option of voting, should you decide to vote.
Prof Eman
Posted: 22 May 2017 14:51:33(UTC)
#9

Joined: 08/04/2010(UTC)
Posts: 480

Please do not forget, last day to register to vote to-day.
Martina
Posted: 22 May 2017 16:49:33(UTC)
#10

Joined: 28/11/2012(UTC)
Posts: 277

Thanks: 4019 times
Was thanked: 401 time(s) in 151 post(s)
Purely out of interest, how many companies since the Brexit vote and the subsequent fall in sterling have fallen into foreign hands a d how many jobs have been transferred?
1 user thanked Martina for this post.
Alan Anderson on 28/05/2017(UTC)
18 Pages123Next page»
+ Reply to discussion

Markets

Other markets