smg8;196695 wrote:Probably inclined to agree with David, I am a holder of Fundsmith too. Really like the way TS communicates his strategy, far better than pretty much any other fund manager I can think of.
I hold 2 x quality funds, FS and Threadneedle Global Focus. Meanwhile Blackrock Global Unconstrained is one of 2 funds I have half an eye on for an end of year portfolio change.
Comparing the 3 year to date leaves FS trailing way behind (20% FS, 27% Threadneedle, 32% Blackrock). The iShares World Quality Index is up 25%.
As always YTD is meaningless in the grand scheme of things, 18th March to now is similarly meaningless. And TS has a superb unmatched track record, so not a criticism of FS at all (I know there are some hardcore fans amongst us :-D) , not a knee jerk, and not saying I or anyone else should switch.
BUT I do think it's worth looking at what the competition is doing from time to time.....
Great food for thought, smg8. My quality holdings are Rathbone Global Opps and FS, so did some comparisons. I didn't have a chance to look at Blackrock but I did look at Threadneedle.
Rebasing some random picks to a starting price of 100 on 1-Feb-19, I got the following returns through to 25-Nov-21,
- TRP 200
- TGF 193
- RGO 190
- BW 185
- FS 170
- Premier Miton Euro Opps 200 (I have a small, lazy position in this fund and hadn't realised just how well it had done)
In fact if you run this time series from 1-Feb-19 to 10-Nov-21 you get PM Euro Opps at 206 making it 4 points clear of TRP.... and they say you need to own US megacaps to outperform!!!
Diving into the portfolios a bit, the size of the top ten concentration between FS and TGF is quite similar - around 49-50% of the portfolio, BW on 53%, TRP is on 33% and RGO is on a lowly 23%. A similar story when looking at P/S - here FS is on 5.4, RGO on 4.0, TRP on 4.7, BW on a punchy 9.8 and TGF on 4.9.
TGF clearly has superior performance with the same valuation metrics and similar vol (4.0% monthly vol compared to 3.7% for FS). In fact it has a marginally better Sharpe ratio (explained by the 23 point performance difference that gets plugged into the numerator).
I'm very happy to keep adding to RGO, but this looks like a solid pick for a FS substitute.
Thanks.