paul armstrong;182992 wrote:Hmm. Why should expenses be in proportion to income ? If you switch a light on, do you see things more brightly, do you pay more at the petrol pump ?😁. I can see a counter argument as costs lie where they fall.
I see your point (and also Money Spider's), but how would one deal with this:
If we bought a £1M house, based on my income of £100K and my wife's £40K, should the mortgage and council tax expenses be 50:50?
Our expensive holidays are possible because of my higher income; how do we split them?
I suspect that both of you are correct and HMRC would take the view that a 50:50 split is the only one possible, but it's an interesting question.
Edit - just did some checking, and if we were to split expenditure 50:50, then as a result of differing incomes, in some years one of us would be in deficit rather than in surplus.
So would the higher-income partner need to allocate some of his surplus to clearing the other's deficit before figuring out the "true" surplus?
Opening a can of worms comes to mind!